Creativity, Mimicry, and Individualism in URAHARA

URAHARA is the meta show Re:Creators wishes it could have been. The series has been getting better every week and is probably the underrated gem of the season.

Be wary of spoilers for URAHARA (up to episode 7)

I know – I also was skeptical of URAHARA initially. At first glance, the title is just another sloppy children’s show with a generic plot. However, I eventually (and rather belatedly) realized that the show has the potential to be introspective and self-referential due to its unique set-up.

In an anime series where creativity is established as being the key to almost everything, the conclusions and the realizations the girls reach in URAHARA could theoretically resonate with viewers since creativity holds similar power in the real world. We just don’t have to deal with alien bandits who steal human culture, fortunately.

And as of episode 7, URAHARA has exceeded my revised expectations and then some.

The big reveal was coming and expected to a degree; Misa and Ebifuruya were clearly up to no good starting from the very first episode. But still, the fact that our main characters were turning into Scoopers due to ingesting the dessert-like Scoopers remains hits the audience hard as their unity as a group unravels like frayed twine. Towards the end of the episode, the rain changes the vibrant alleys of Urahara into dull, muted shadows. Rito can only stare in horror as Mari and Kotoko seemingly accept that they will transform into Scoopers and mindlessly tear into the nebulous treats responsible for their metamorphosis like they were wild beasts eating regurgitated waste off the floor.

Wow. What happened to the children’s story? What happened to Mari and Kotoko?

vlcsnap-2017-11-15-17h27m49s390

Well, I believe the two girls largely fell prey to several layers of mindgames and manipulation (courtesy of the Scoopers and Ebifuruya). Furthermore, their own personalities, which were initially presented as sparkling and bright like their store wares, are finally revealed to be fragile and then shatter like glass, allowing their disorientated minds to surrender to insecurities and stop resisting.

But at the center of all this is the concept of creativity.

It’s not much of a stretch to say that creativity is what defines human culture. Creativity created and erected monuments. Creativity is what allows novels to be written and anime series to be produced. One would be hard-pressed to find someone who thinks creativity is a negative trait.

It’s a bit less clear-cut when you try to define the limits of creativity, however. Kotoko’s uncertain question, which is the catalyst that ends up tearing the group apart and leaving the girls vulnerable, did exactly that since she asked, “Scoopers steal culture, don’t they? Maybe we’ve been doing the same thing [via imitation and mimicry].” Unable to accept that the implication that her sense of creativity is fake and copied and scared of how she could completely lose her creativity by transforming into a Scooper, Mari storms out of Park (but not before Kotoko reveals that she was considering Ebifuruya’s sweet yet poisonous words – more on that later).

vlcsnap-2017-11-15-17h30m21s330.jpg

It’s important to consider how Mari and Rito interpret Kotoko’s statement very differently. For Mari, being accused of imitating others’ fashion sense and dance moves is an insult that implies she is simply not creative. Her mentality reflects the contemporary beliefs regarding visual arts, which places a heavy emphasis on the importance of originality and uniqueness. Rito, however, isn’t as quick to become offended at Kotoko’s words and states that imitating others isn’t necessarily bad. Rito’s mindset aligns with that of Renaissance artists. For instance, a young apprentice is encouraged to seek out and copy the styles and forms of the very best artists according to an excerpt from Cennino Cennini’s The Artist’s Handbook, which was published in 1400 CE. Cennini confidently claims that “through dedicated and repetitive imitation and emulation of works of art that inspire, one will eventually be skilled enough to reveal his own style” (Gardener 431). Perhaps it’s not just a coincidence that Rito is an artist since she shares that sort of mentality.

The dissimilarities don’t stop there. Although the girls were all feeling scared about how they might be losing the ability to be creative, Rito attempts to encourage Mari and Kotoko by saying they can work together to reclaim creativity. In response, however, Mari lashes out at Rito and claims Rito is lucky to be able to draw by herself. Perhaps Mari is bitter that she isn’t as talented as Rito when it comes to drawing so she requires Rito’s assistance when she sketches out her clothing brands – the meaning of Mari’s statement is kept vague. Be that as it may, this heated exchange reveals that the value of teamwork and the value of individuality differs for Rito, Mari, and even Kotoko.

For Rito, staying with her friends is even more important than being individually talented or creative according to the events in this episode and her conversation with Sayumin. Despite being afraid that they’re all too different, Rito receives some encouragement from Sayumin who claims that they are collectively like sakuramochi and that they come together to become harmonious and delicious despite how each component is so radically different.

vlcsnap-2017-11-15-17h31m19s498.jpg

Meanwhile, Mari’s aspirations to become popular and famous as an idol and actress crash down on her as her follower count takes a straight nosedive from 246,000 to 0 following her outburst. A flashback in which she received praise and recognition from imitating other dancers’ moves (namely that of Ariana Grande’s), along with her reciting fashion trends from magazines in earlier flashbacks, reveals that Mari has likely been copying others her entire life. Remaining heavily in denial, craving both praise and attention, trying to cling onto her individualistic dream, and refusing to accept all artists borrow from others to a degree, Mari falls into despair.

While it would appear that Kotoko also prioritizes staying together over her own goals since she wanders around Urahara trying to find the others, Kotoko happens to hold private motives that disregard everyone else’s feelings. Tired of being mocked for being weird or strange, Kotoko dreams of a sancutary where she can be herself and with Mari and Rito. The thing is, including her friends seems more like an afterthought considering she admits to enjoy being praised by the other two. In other words, the other two are implied to be kept around just to bolster her self-esteem. Furthermore, the poisoned honey Ebifuruya whispered into her conscious involved the three of them being together forever as if trapped in an eternal Spring Break, which Kotoko finds enticing. Before Mari stormed out of Park, Kotoko admits that if they do lose their creativity, then she would like to just do endless research with Rito and Mari by her side. In short, she just focuses on her own desires and doesn’t try to understand how others feel, just like what Mari accused Kotoko of doing before she left Park.

vlcsnap-2017-11-15-17h36m31s974.jpg

Mari herself falls prey to Ebifuruya’s sweet words, however, after he implies that strong Scoopers can modify their faces and become cute to everyone. For an aspiring idol and actress, that sort of ability is very powerful and tempting. Furthermore, it’s implied that the Scoopers have infiltrated the town considering how Mari’s followers were dropping despite the lack of internet; how the crowds were rather nebulous, hateful, and were dyed an unnatural shade of purple; and how said crowds cheered on Mari as she defeated Scoopers, which convinces Mari to continue fighting Scoopers in order to receive the fame she desperately craved.

The only problem is that the girls need to ingest the remains of Scoopers to continue squaring off against said opponents. The fact that the Scoopers’ remains seems to have momentarily caused Rito to become brainwashed until she caught a glimpse of Sayumin’s sakuramochi also seems to imply that this was sealed the deal for Mari and Kotoko. Out of duty and reflex, the three girls fought against the Scoopers, which automatically leave their dessert remains upon being defeated, which tempts the girls on top of the other layers of manipulation and stress they’re dealing with.

And thus the stage is set. Perhaps the Scoopers’ subtle influences were what pushed Mari and Kotoko off the edge. But the viewer will be amiss to discredit how the girls clashed in terms of philosophy and what it means to be creative, which left the girls all alone and vulnerable to outside factors (save Rito, who ran into Sayumin). And don’t forget that this entire situation started because of the power of creativity. One would be foolish to dismiss its power.


Gardener’s Art Through the Ages: A Western Perspective, Vol., 2, 13th Ed., by Fred Kleiner, Cenage Learning, Copyright 2009, Pg 431

12 thoughts on “Creativity, Mimicry, and Individualism in URAHARA

  1. I became immediately more interested in Urahara shortly after the theme of limitations of creativity were brought to light. To a degree us human beings do imitate and are inspired by other people, however I’d have to disagree that that is the extent of creativity. This implies that creativity is simply a rearrangement of pre-existing ideas hence the saying “there’s nothing new under the sun”, just as the author Jeff Goins explains in his book, Real Artists Don’t Starve.

    As an illustrator and musician I can name off the top of my head many of the artists that have inspired my craft (Hamauzu Masashi, Ling Tosite Sigure, Arvo Part, Shimomura Yoko, Shinkawa Yoji, The Whitest Boy Alive, etc.), however I don’t believe I’m simply a bag of meat through which I regurgitate existing works.

    Human creativity in a way is a Great Conversation so we’re going to share existing ideas and place our own spin on the discussion that is the human experience, but there’s also room for novelty. The belief that creativity is simply stealing, mimicry, or rearrangement is a pragmatic one but limits the potential for new works to be created.

    As far as I know Life Online is so amazingly complex that I’ll never know where inspiration may strike, especially since we can’t fathom the worlds and concepts beyond our limited sensory experience.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Had a feeling this show was going to have a “Madoka twist”* moment eventually since episode 1, and was not disappointed in the least! Really liking the direction the show has been going in and excited to see more.

    Great posts talking about the show and its themes, honestly. A lot of things I wouldn’t have thought of myself, including how meta the show really is under the surface. Hidden gem of the season, indeed.

    (*By this I mean a twist several episodes into a show in which information is revealed that changes everything about the events leading up to said episode, for examples, Madoka’s episode/scene where Kyuubey finally reveals what magical girls really are and what Soul Gems really are, Yuuki Yuuna and when Mankai(/”Blooming”) is fully revealed, and this episode of this show. There probably are earlier shows that have similar twists, but Madoka is the most obvious one that comes to my mind, so I use it.)

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Ah, that was sharp of you. It’s been a great ride and I’m embarrassed I doubted the show at first.

      Thank you. I feel like I’ve only scratched the surface, honestly. URAHARA has quite some depth!

      (No worries, it’s all good. I would use the same term, too, since the titular scene is just so iconic).

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Honestly, I mostly had that feeling due to the art style they use for the eyes being almost exactly the same as, or very similar to, Madoka’s eye style. Suspicious Ebifuruya (aka new Kyuubey 2017) certainly didn’t help my suspicions, and I did have a few moments during episodes 3-6 where I wondered whether I had been mistaken, but it seems I was on the right track after all.

        Liked by 1 person

  3. Yay, thanks for spreading the word. Liking Urahara feels less lonely.

    I expected something like this to happen… around episode 10, and I didn’t expect it to hit quite that hard. Also, the Object of Bonding got abandonded in the rain. That’s rather unusual (though since they’re eating stuff off the ground anyway, who knows?).

    Excellent episode.

    I agree with Zeria, about the teaching element, and it’s also a lesson for our girls. Remember the scooper from episode one, the one with the strange outfit who wore a shachihoko on his head? That one basically made the same mistake as Misa originally made with her bracelet – just randomly bunching stuff together.

    Creativity, paradoxically, needs rules to reproduce as much as free space to develop. A simple way to put it: you can’t write a poem without knowing a language. Something entirely new is going to be incomprehensible.

    So that’s sort of also the way to answer our girls’ anxieties. If you can teach people to be creative, then imitating stuff you like is pretty much a normal part of the process.

    Liked by 2 people

    1. No problem! Not enough people are talking about URAHARA, after all.

      Mmm the series is having the girls hit rock bottom earlier than expected and it’s incredibly effective. Thankfully the sakuramochi was inside the box so it should still be good for consumption.

      Ohhh good point about how the episode 1 Scooper and Misa both slapped things together haphazardly. But Misa was able to successfully complete her ornament which means the Scoopers /can/ “create something out of nothing” after receiving a little guidance. Of course, Misa only did so after imitation like you said, but it’s not a bad thing overall. It’s just normal.

      Hopefully Mari can come to terms with that.

      Liked by 1 person

    1. I want to recommend it, but it’s also not for everyone. Still, I really like it!

      It might not knock you off your feet at first, but I really do think it gets better.

      Fangs are life.

      Like

  4. I think the direction the show goes from here is influenced by episode 6. The fact that Misa was actually able to create something shows that those who began as scoopers can become creative. I think Rito will help the others by showing the scoopers that they’re able to be creative as well, if they draw upon others(as all artists do).

    Liked by 2 people

    1. Ah, good point. With a little encouragement from the others Misa did make a rad ring. Very interesting on how they (they being Misa and Ebi) accepted that without causing too much of a fuss or considering the implications while proceeding with their original plan. Perhaps they already invested too much into the default plan by then.

      Your prediction sounds spot-on and would make perfect sense thematically. I’m looking forward to seeing if you’re correct!

      Hopefully Mari can come to terms with that (and I’ll probably have to rephrase some parts later. Thank you).

      Liked by 1 person

I-it's not like I want you to leave a comment or anything. B-baka.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s